lichess.org
Donate

ChessBase and lichess PGN - variants/960

Mainly ChessBase related issues - but since this is commonly used software:
1. PGN attributes
After playing variants for a while, my PGN game download has a big mix of all types of games.
This makes finding some games by type hard since ChessBase does not expose variant in any of the game list views.

So can lichess please change the Event attribute from:
{Rated/Casual} Game
to
{Variant} {Rated/Casual} Game
E.g. Chess960 Rated Game
for the sake of sorting games and seeing quite clearly what is being played?

2. PGN for 960
ChessBase/Fritz has trouble handling the PGN getting generated by lichess. One example from my games is when white castles on move 23 http://en.lichess.org/314SwIWx#24 (PGN export: http://en.lichess.org/game/export/314SwIWx.pgn)
ChessBase does not recognize this move and this starts a knock-on effect of pieces being in the wrong place for subsequent moves.
Firstly, can anyone else confirm this happens in their ChessBase?
Secondly the only differences I see between Fritz generated headers and lichess are:
Lichess:
[Variant "Chess960"]
[FEN "rbbqnknr/pppppppp/8/8/8/8/PPPPPPPP/RBBQNKNR w KQkq - 0 1"]

Fritz/ChessBase:
[Variant "chess 960"]
[FEN "rbbqnknr/pppppppp/8/8/8/8/PPPPPPPP/RBBQNKNR w HAha - 0 1"]

After testing, looks like the variant does not matter (Chess960 or chess 960)... the Haha vs KQkq is what counts. The description of how this works is found here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Forsyth%E2%80%93Edwards_Notation
"The solution implemented by chess engines like Shredder and Fritz_9 is to use the letters of the columns on which the rooks began the game. This scheme is sometimes called Shredder-FEN. For the traditional setup, Shredder-FEN would use AHah instead of KQkq."

Can lichess please move to that so we can analyze our 960 games with ChessBase?

Lastly, I see that the 960 position number is found on top left during game play. Can this be put in the PGN somewhere too? (Maybe from above Chess960 (287)... this makes finding the 960 position much easier in Fritz.)

Thanks!
КАК ПОНЯТЬ ЭТО - АНТИШАХМАТЫ. КАКАЯ ЦЕЛЬ
I have the same problem. Would be awesome if this could be changed. The notation used by Fritz and Shredder is actually better because "kingside" and "queenside" can each contain two rooks in the middle game, so it's unclear with which rook castling is allowed.

This topic has been archived and can no longer be replied to.